One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Location, Privacy, Location, Value, Location. Welcome to the BEST non Gulf front setting in Sanderling on Siesta Key. This fully updated home sits on a acre lot with an adjacent co owned acre lot, giving you the benefit and privacy of over 1.5 acres on a private island in the middle of Sanderling. It is grandfathered to remain as a one level home with no steps, allowing you to enjoy it indefinitely as your dream home or design and build a future residence on Plover. Set within the gates of the exclusive Sanderling Club on Siesta Key, this exceptional 3 bedroom, 3.5 bath residence presents a rare opportunity to own in one of the islands most private and storied coastal communities. The Sanderling is a member owned Gulf to Bay enclave celebrated for its low density design, lush tropical landscape, iconic banyan canopy, and unparalleled access to Siesta Keys world famous quartz sand beach. Residents enjoy boat slips for lease, both clay and hard tennis courts, pickleball courts, clubhouse amenities, and guard gated security. Beautifully positioned among mature tropical landscaping, the home blends timeless charm with high quality upgrades and thoughtful improvements. Impact rated windows and doors provide security, energy efficiency, and peace of mind. A brand new roof was installed in 2025, and the home is insulated throughout with Isonene foam insulation for excellent climate control and quieter interiors. Inside, the home is warm, bright, and designed for relaxed coastal living. The main living spaces feature abundant natural light and tranquil garden views through large windows and sliders that connect seamlessly to the surrounding greenery. A rare feature for Siesta Key, the living room includes a fully functioning wood burning fireplace, creating a cozy focal point for cooler winter evenings. The open living and dining areas offer flexible space for entertaining or everyday comfort, while the kitchen provides generous workspace, ample cabinetry, and excellent flow to the surrounding rooms. In addition to the three bedrooms, the home includes a comfortable office ideal for remote work or quiet reading, along with a large walk in pantry providing exceptional storage and organization. The primary suite is privately situated and offers peaceful views, generous closet space, and an en suite bath designed for comfort and functionality. Two additional guest suites, each with their own private bathrooms, provide excellent accommodations for family and visitors, while a convenient half bath serves the main living areas. Outdoor living is one of the homes greatest attributes. Surrounded by mature landscaping and the Sanderlings natural canopy, the grounds feel serene and secluded. A beautifully installed turf lawn creates a low maintenance outdoor space ideal for pets, play, or lounging, while a dedicated fire pit area offers the perfect place to gather in the evenings and enjoy the soft Gulf breezes. As a resident of the Sanderling Club, youll enjoy access to a members only beachfront, clubhouse amenities, tennis and pickleball courts, and boat access. The Sanderling Clubhouse renovation has been approved and is underway, further enhancing the communitys already exceptional amenities. This bright and inviting island home is truly a must see, offering an extraordinary combination of privacy, setting, and lifestyle in one of Siesta Keys most cherished communities.
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Location, Privacy, Location, Value, Location. Welcome to the BEST non Gulf front setting in Sanderling on Siesta Key. This fully updated home sits on a acre lot with an adjacent co owned acre lot, giving you the benefit and privacy of over 1.5 acres on a private island in the middle of Sanderling. It is grandfathered to remain as a one level home with no steps, allowing you to enjoy it indefinitely as your dream home or design and build a future residence on Plover. Set within the gates of the exclusive Sanderling Club on Siesta Key, this exceptional 3 bedroom, 3.5 bath residence presents a rare opportunity to own in one of the islands most private and storied coastal communities. The Sanderling is a member owned Gulf to Bay enclave celebrated for its low density design, lush tropical landscape, iconic banyan canopy, and unparalleled access to Siesta Keys world famous quartz sand beach. Residents enjoy boat slips for lease, both clay and hard tennis courts, pickleball courts, clubhouse amenities, and guard gated security. Beautifully positioned among mature tropical landscaping, the home blends timeless charm with high quality upgrades and thoughtful improvements. Impact rated windows and doors provide security, energy efficiency, and peace of mind. A brand new roof was installed in 2025, and the home is insulated throughout with Isonene foam insulation for excellent climate control and quieter interiors. Inside, the home is warm, bright, and designed for relaxed coastal living. The main living spaces feature abundant natural light and tranquil garden views through large windows and sliders that connect seamlessly to the surrounding greenery. A rare feature for Siesta Key, the living room includes a fully functioning wood burning fireplace, creating a cozy focal point for cooler winter evenings. The open living and dining areas offer flexible space for entertaining or everyday comfort, while the kitchen provides generous workspace, ample cabinetry, and excellent flow to the surrounding rooms. In addition to the three bedrooms, the home includes a comfortable office ideal for remote work or quiet reading, along with a large walk in pantry providing exceptional storage and organization. The primary suite is privately situated and offers peaceful views, generous closet space, and an en suite bath designed for comfort and functionality. Two additional guest suites, each with their own private bathrooms, provide excellent accommodations for family and visitors, while a convenient half bath serves the main living areas. Outdoor living is one of the homes greatest attributes. Surrounded by mature landscaping and the Sanderlings natural canopy, the grounds feel serene and secluded. A beautifully installed turf lawn creates a low maintenance outdoor space ideal for pets, play, or lounging, while a dedicated fire pit area offers the perfect place to gather in the evenings and enjoy the soft Gulf breezes. As a resident of the Sanderling Club, youll enjoy access to a members only beachfront, clubhouse amenities, tennis and pickleball courts, and boat access. The Sanderling Clubhouse renovation has been approved and is underway, further enhancing the communitys already exceptional amenities. This bright and inviting island home is truly a must see, offering an extraordinary combination of privacy, setting, and lifestyle in one of Siesta Keys most cherished communities.
Features
Building and Construction
Covered Spaces: 0.00
Exterior Features: Lighting
Flooring: Tile, Wood
Living Area: 2748.00
Other Structures: Shed(s)
Roof: Shingle
Property Information
Property Condition: Completed
Land Information
Lot Features: In County, Level, Oversized Lot, Private
School Information
High School: Sarasota High
Middle School: Brookside Middle
School Elementary: Phillippi Shores Elementary
Garage and Parking
Garage Spaces: 0.00
Open Parking Spaces: 0.00
Eco-Communities
Pool Features: In Ground
Water Source: Public
Utilities
Carport Spaces: 0.00
Cooling: Central Air
Heating: Central
Pets Allowed: Yes
Sewer: Public Sewer
Utilities: Public
Finance and Tax Information
Home Owners Association Fee: 450.00
Insurance Expense: 0.00
Net Operating Income: 0.00
Other Expense: 0.00
Tax Year: 2025
Other Features
Appliances: Other
Association Name: Amy - Pinnacle
Country: US
Furnished: Unfurnished
Interior Features: Other
Legal Description: LOT 8 LESS NLY 50 FT & N 100 FT OF LOT 7 SIESTA PROPERTIES INC UNIT 4
Levels: One
Area Major: 34242 - Sarasota/Crescent Beach/Siesta Key
Fantastic opportunity to own a unique home on Palm Island, in this exceptional Siesta Key residence, ideally located at 5334 Calle Florida. Situated on a large lot and elevated approximately 10 feet a
Effortless Island Living on Siesta Keys Coveted North End.
Discover the perfect blend of modern luxury and low maintenance living in this
contemporary coastal retreat, ideally located on the quiet N
Situated in the sought after Bay Isle community on Siesta Key, this exceptional three level pool home combines the best of upscale coastal living with impressive rental performance. Designed to host g
Welcome your Siesta Key dream home Commonwealth Drive, a stunning custom residence located directly on the Grand Canal. This four bedroom, four bathroom home exudes island style and warmth from the mo
New Listings & Price Reduction Updates sent directly to your email
Create Your Own Property Search saved for your return visit.
"Like" Listings and Create a Favorites List
* NOTICE: By creating your free profile, you authorize us to send you periodic emails about new listings that match your saved searches and related real estate information.If you provide your telephone number, you are giving us permission to call you in response to this request, even if this phone number is in the State and/or National Do Not Call Registry.